Social worker denied Australian work visa due to blindness

March 19 2010 by Liam Clifford

The Australian Immigration Department is facing criticism over its refusal to grant a visa to a highly qualified social worker from India because she is legally blind.

Simran Kaur, 29, arrived in Melbourne in 2007 on a student visa with her husband, Jasmeet Singh. She had obtained a master's degree in social work in India and came to Australia to earn a diploma in community welfare and development.

Ms. Kaur’s vision is described as 6/60, meaning she is not completely blind. She was born with retinal macular dystrophy and her condition is considered stable. She is able to live independently despite her poor vision and has worked as a social worker in India.

In February, Ms. Kaur’s application for a permanent 886 skilled-sponsored Australian work visa was rejected, after a medical examination by a Commonwealth medical officer assessed her as not meeting health requirements. The officer said she met the criteria for legal blindness and she would be eligible for the blind or disability pension ''in due course'', explaining: ''Such a person with this condition and severity, staying for the proposed duration of stay (permanent), would likely require the … blind or disability pension. This would result in significant cost to the Australian community."

Ms. Kaur’s immigration lawyer, Stephanie Booker, said her client would contribute to, rather than take from, Australian society. She has pledged to apply to the minister to intervene if her client’s appeal against the department's visa refusal should fail: ''We feel particularly impassioned about this case because it's just blatant discrimination because of her disability'' she said.

See the latest Immigration News