TV immigration experiment proves employers need foreigners to work in the UK

February 25 2010 by Liam Clifford

A BBC documentary which aired last night has highlighted the British economy’s need for foreign migrants to work in the UK in roles that indigenous Britons are not able or willing to do.

‘The Day The Immigrants Left’, a film by broadcaster Evan Davis, took a dozen unemployed people in Wisbech, East Anglia, for a couple of days and gave them jobs usually filled by migrant workers, such as farm work, packing potatoes, serving in an Indian restaurant, and building.
Approximately 9,000 immigrants from Central and Eastern Europe have come to work in the UK, choosing the Wisbech area, since the EU was expanded in 2004.

Philip Doughty, from Wisbech, took part in the experiment after complaining there were no suitable jobs for him. He spent two days picking asparagus and found that his productivity was less than half that of a typical migrant worker. He conceded: “If I had a farm, I’d employ [migrant workers] any day.”

The Office for National Statistics published some facts last year that shed light on the recent trends in UK immigration: of those born in the UK, 16% are employed in managerial roles – almost the same volume of people as are employed at the traditional unskilled end of the labour market (18%). Migrant workers from Central and Eastern Europe, who do not need UK work visas, overwhelmingly take positions at the unskilled end of the labour spectrum and fill a gap left by the traditional British working class.

See the latest Immigration News